Free Case ReviewHolladay PT · Virtual coaching anywhere, no travelNo referral · One-on-one with Dr. Emily, DPT, Cert. MDT
Let’s talk about helping you feel better. Request a Free Case Review
Holladay PT clinic, serving Greater Salt Lake City · Virtual coaching from anywhere, no travel needed · Call (385) 332-4939 · Text us · Strong Bones Strength Class
No referral needed for in-person PT. Dedicated one-on-one visits with Dr. Emily Warren, DPT, Cert. MDT — McKenzie certified.

“Spinal decompression” can mean very different things: an operation or treatment on a traction machine. If you are comparing a machine-based treatment with the McKenzie Method, we can help you understand the difference. Our focus is finding helpful movement and teaching you a plan you can use beyond the appointment.

One-on-one PT with Dr. Emily Warren, DPT, Cert. MDT. No referral needed. In-person care in Holladay, serving Greater Salt Lake City, and virtual coaching from anywhere.

Request a Free Case Review

Machine-based decompression and McKenzie care

Question What to consider
What happens during treatment? A traction machine applies a pulling force. McKenzie assessment tests how symptoms respond to selected movements and positions.
What happens between appointments? Ask a traction provider what active plan accompanies treatment. In McKenzie care, we teach the selected home practice and how to monitor its response.
How do we check value? Look for changes in symptoms and daily activity rather than relying on claims about discs moving back into place.
Dr. Emily Warren providing one-on-one back care to a patient on a treatment table at Mindful Movement PT
Dr. Emily Warren providing one-on-one back care at Mindful Movement PT.
Dr. Emily Warren, DPT, Cert. MDT, at Mindful Movement Physical Therapy
Dr. Emily Warren
DPT, Cert. MDT

Get a clear plan at your first visit with Dr. Emily

Emily’s early work in neurological rehabilitation shaped her interest in movement, pain and what people want to get back to.

Emily is a credentialed McKenzie therapist. Your history and response to repeated movements help her decide what to practice and what to change; extension is not automatically the right direction. You learn what to notice between visits so the plan can be reviewed against daily life.

Meet Emily and explore her approach · Request a Free Case Review to discuss how to understand which movements help you.

Two different meanings

Surgical decompression is an operation intended to address pressure on neural structures in selected circumstances. Its indications, risks and recovery should be discussed with a surgeon.

Nonsurgical decompression often refers to a traction-based device or treatment. Ask exactly what the treatment involves and which evidence supports its use for your presentation. The name does not establish that it changes disc anatomy.

What a McKenzie assessment does

Mechanical Diagnosis and Therapy assesses symptoms and responses to movement to help select a management plan. It is not a mechanical substitute for an indicated operation and does not promise to pull a disc back into place.

Read the McKenzie service explanation.

Making sense of imaging and pain with Dr. Emily

Dr. Emily explains why an imaging finding does not always tell the whole story of pain. Bring your questions so we can connect your report with your symptoms and goals.

Key points from the video

  • Dr. Emily uses an overflowing-cup analogy to explain how several factors can contribute to pain.
  • Imaging findings, activity, sleep, stress and sensitivity can all be part of the picture.
  • The message is that you may have options for improving pain and activity without having to change every scan finding.

Watch on YouTube

How can you compare a decompression package with a PT plan?

Ask for the treatment name, the problem it is intended to address and a useful way to judge progress. Then compare the written proposals with the same everyday activity in mind. A machine setting, number of visits or reassuring scan explanation does not answer those questions for you.

First, write which recommendation you have actually received: a traction-machine package, an assessment-based PT plan or an operation. If the proposal is surgical decompression, ask your surgeon about its reason and timing. A machine-based service and a movement assessment are different options with different purposes; neither automatically replaces an indicated operation.

A comparison sheet to use before committing

Use paper or your own notes app. Record the answers for each proposal, including a question that has not yet been answered. You can bring the sheet to Emily or the clinician who made the recommendation.

Five questions for each proposed treatment
Question What to record
What diagnosis or findings support this recommendation? The exact treatment and which symptoms or examination findings it addresses. Ask how a scan finding relates to the difficulty you want help with.
What outcome is realistic and how will it be measured? One activity, such as your usual commute or grocery trip. Record what currently limits it and what a worthwhile change would look like.
What are the risks, limitations and alternatives? The provider’s explanation, relevant precautions and any medical or surgical questions that still need an answer.
When will the plan change if it is not helping? An agreed review point, what you will compare and who to contact if symptoms change. Ask what finding would prompt another assessment.
What is the cost and what does it include? The total proposed commitment, what is included, and the options if the initial approach is not helping enough. Ask before committing to a package.

How do you know whether relief is carrying into your day?

Keep a brief note of your usual activity before care, the response immediately afterward and what happens later in the day. If helpful and comfortable, note the next morning too. This is an observation of ordinary life, not a challenge to repeatedly provoke pain. A short-lived change and a more manageable activity are both useful information, but they are not the same outcome.

Be cautious about treating a temporary symptom change as proof of anatomical healing.

Dr. Emily’s assessment starts with your experience and the task you want back. You practice a selected strategy together and agree what to notice between visits. When the change is not carrying into daily life, that is a reason to review the plan and wider care options. Read what to reassess when previous PT has not helped enough.

What you can work on beyond a treatment session

When comparing a traction package with an assessment-based exercise plan, ask what you will learn to do between visits. Temporary relief can be useful, but the plan should also address sitting, walking, lifting or the activity you want back.

The difference we want you to understand is what you can do after the appointment. Dr. Emily uses McKenzie assessment to look for a helpful movement response, teaches a home strategy and retests a task that matters to you. Our McKenzie research guide explains where the evidence is encouraging and which patients were studied. We then build strength and activity so the plan develops beyond temporary relief.

  • Ask for the goal of each treatment and a meaningful way to measure it.
  • Keep a record of whether relief carries into your next activity.
  • Discuss progressive strength and endurance rather than relying only on the treatment table.

If a surgeon has recommended decompression, ask the surgeon about the reason and urgency; a home exercise response does not answer that question. Explore individual back-pain care.

Choosing a next step

If you have been told you need a treatment package because your back is deteriorating, bring the proposed plan and the report behind it. Emily can assess your movement and function, explain what an active plan could address and agree on what progress would look like. If an operation is being considered, keep that decision coordinated with your surgical team.

See the surgery decision guide and disc-related PT service.

In-person or virtual PT

Dr. Emily Warren, DPT, Cert. MDT, offers individual care in Holladay, serving Greater Salt Lake City. Virtual visits may suit discussion, guided movement or home-plan review; some symptoms require in-person examination or medical assessment.

Frequently asked questions

Is a decompression machine the same as spinal decompression surgery?

No. A machine-based treatment generally refers to traction; surgery is a different procedure intended to address a specific structural problem. Ask which treatment is being proposed and why. NICE does not recommend traction for managing low back pain with or without sciatica.

What does a McKenzie assessment add to a treatment decision?

It examines how your symptoms respond to movements and positions, helping guide a management plan. At Mindful Movement, the useful outcome is a clearer explanation and practical next step, including a home strategy when appropriate. It does not promise to pull a disc back into place.

Evidence and further reading

Does traction add lasting benefit? Traction showed little or no important benefit across mixed low-back-pain groups (Wegner, Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2013). For lumbar radiculopathy, supine traction added to PT gave short-term benefit in lower-quality studies, while higher-quality prone-traction studies showed no significant benefit (Vanti, Physical Therapy, 2021). The population, technique and accompanying care matter.

The McKenzie trial results and assessment explanation address a different treatment approach and selected movement-responsive symptoms. These are separate evidence streams, not a head-to-head trial showing one option wins for everyone. At MMPT, Emily examines your response, practices the selected movement with you and checks whether it makes daily activity easier.

Google review: Alex B.

“Emily is excellent! Treatment is goal-oriented and pragmatic. I enjoy my sessions.”

Choose care with a clearer picture

Before choosing a decompression package or an exercise plan, ask what it is intended to change, what you can practice at home and how progress will be judged. Bring those questions to Emily so we can discuss what a movement assessment would add.

In your Free Case Review, we’ll listen to what you want back, answer your questions and help you decide whether care with Mindful Movement fits. Send a request and you’ll hear from us the same day, by phone or text.

Request a Free Case Review

Dedicated one-on-one PT with Dr. Emily Warren, DPT, Cert. MDT—McKenzie certified. No referral needed. Your first PT visit is 60 minutes for assessment, explanation and a starting plan practiced together. The Free Case Review is a conversation before care.

In-person care at our Holladay clinic, serving Greater Salt Lake City. Virtual coaching from anywhere.

Call/text (385) 332-4939.

Free Case ReviewCallText